LRIS on 02/07/2025

Timing Of Police Transfer Alone Not Sufficient To Establish Anti-Union Animus

Nick Martens was a police officer in the city of Marion, Iowa. Martens also served as the president of the Marion Policeman’s Protective Association. In that capacity, Martens sent an email to management reporting a complaint on behalf of a Union member which alleged­ly contained factual inaccuracie

LRIS on 02/07/2025

Individual Officer Lacks Standing To Appeal Discipline Arbitration Award

Leroy Williams, a special police officer with the District of Columbia’s Department of General Services (DGS), was terminated in August 2019 for conduct relating to two unauthorized traffic stops the previous March. Upon receiving a final notice of separation, Williams was presented with three optio

LRIS on 02/07/2025

NJ Distressed City Law Does Not Preempt Arbitration Award Requiring Acting Pay

The Paterson Deputy Fire Chiefs Association represents Deputy Fire Chiefs in the City of Paterson, New Jersey. For about ten years, the City has been designated as a “city in dis­tress” by the New Jersey Department of Community Affairs (DCA). As a result, the City entered into a Mem­orandum of Under

LRIS on 02/07/2025

Washington County Illegally Required Mandatory OT As A Condition Of Employment

In 2014, King County began to signal to the King County Correc­tions Guild that it wished to include mandatory overtime in the “essential functions form” that it had been pro­viding to doctors for the purposes of assessing disability accommodations. Historically, mandatory overtime, along with volun

LRIS on 02/07/2025

Court Instructs That Lawyers Matter In Dismissing Sergeant’s Speech Lawsuit

Thad Brockett worked in the Effing­ham County, Illinois Sheriff’s Depart­ment from July 1996 until December 2014. From 2012-2014, Brockett was promoted by Sheriff John Monnet to serve as Operations Sergeant, supervising and overseeing the jail, telecommunica­tions, and court security personnel. Righ

LRIS on 01/10/2025

Police Chief’s Private Texts To Coworker Not Protected By First Amendment

Kate Adams was hired by the Sacramento County Sheriff’s Department in 1994, and by March 2020, she had worked her way up to Chief of Police for the City of Rancho Cordova in California. Her time in the position, however, was short-lived, as Adams was forced to resign the following year after allegat

LRIS on 01/10/2025

No Speech Protections For False Statements

In 2015, the Internal Affairs Unit of the Sunnyvale Department of Public Safety in California opened an investigation into David Meinhardt, an officer who also happened to be the president of the Sunnyvale Public Safety Officers’ Association. IA was following up on a complaint that Meinhardt was usi

LRIS on 01/10/2025

Back Pay, Not Reinstatement, For LAPD Officer Dealt A Due Process Violation

Like many municipalities across the country, the City of Los Angeles declared an emergency in March 2020 in response to COVID-19. The following August, the City passed an ordinance that required all City employees to be vaccinated against COVID-19, request an exemption, or be subject to “appropriate

LRIS on 01/10/2025

City Council Had Authority To Fire Police Officer After High-Speed Chase

Gregory Moliere served as a police officer in the Buffalo Police Department in Texas. Despite department policy to the contrary, Moliere engaged in a high-speed chase while a civilian was riding along in his patrol vehicle. The chase resulted in an accident that damaged the patrol vehicle. Moliere r

LRIS on 01/10/2025

Privacy Concerns Did Not Outweigh Union’s Need For Sanitized Misconduct Forms

American Federation of Government Employees Local 3584, representing a unit of correctional workers, made an information request to the Department of Justice’s Office of Internal Affairs on behalf of its members at FCI Dublin, a low-security federal prison in California. The Union believed that the

LRIS on 01/10/2025

City Of Chicago Not Liable For COVID Death Of Officer

On March 9, 2020, the Governor of Illinois issued a Disaster Proclamation, and on March 13, the President declared a National Emergency related to COVID-19. The Proclamation declared that COVID-19 can lead to “serious, long-term complications in some cases.” According to the Centers for Disease Cont

LRIS on 01/10/2025

Pension Benefits Properly Denied To Disabled Officer Who Refused Surgery

In March 2019, Aaron Shirley, a police sergeant for the Clarendon Hills Police Department in Illinois, was injured on duty while assisting paramedics in restraining a minor lying on a cot. While restraining the minor, Shirley felt a “pop” in his right shoulder and later experienced severe pain and d

LRIS on 01/10/2025

Illinois County Had Legitimate Reason To Lay Off All Commanders At Once

In 2017, the Teamsters were conducting an organizing campaign among the commanders in the Cook County Department of Corrections, a subdivision of the Cook County Sheriff’s Office. The Sheriff’s Office opposed the inclusion of commanders, who they viewed as managerial employees. In August of that yea

LRIS on 12/13/2024

Discrimination, Weingarten Allegations Must Allege Deprivations

Jasmine Johnson-Purnell is a Licensed Practical Nurse employed by the Washington State Department of Corrections at the Washington Corrections Center in Shelton. She was part of a nonsupervisory unit represented by Teamsters Local 117. In January 2024, Johnson-Purnell was assigned new medication car

LRIS on 12/13/2024

Absolute Immunity For Philly DA Despite Biased Prosecution Of Police Officer

Ryan Pownall is a Philadelphia police officer who was terminated and criminally charged after fatally shooting David Jones following a dispute over Jones’ operation of a dirt bike. Terrance Freeman, who was riding in the back seat of Pownall’s police vehicle, witnessed the shooting. Jones was taken

LRIS on 12/13/2024

Civil Immunity Not Automatic For Officer Working Off-Duty Private Detail

In January 2019, the Nickerson Post, a banquet hall in Quincy, Massachusetts, hired Paul Keenan and Christopher Bulger to provide private police detail at a concert. Keenan was chief of the City’s police department, and Bulger was an officer in that department. That evening, the Nickerson Post was o

LRIS on 12/13/2024

City Interest Arbitration Ordinance Restored Following 13-Year Legal Battle

Until 2011, Article V of the charter of the City of Palo Alto, California required binding interest arbitration for certain labor disputes with its public safety unions. Facing a budget crisis in 2010 and 2011, the City council proposed modifying Article V to require cheaper dispute resolution proc

LRIS on 12/13/2024

Grievance Board Erred In Upholding CO’s Use Of Force Termination

Troy Carter was a correctional officer and shift supervisor with the rank of lieutenant at the Department of Homeland Security (DHS), Southern Regional Jail and Correctional Facility in West Virginia. Carter received a call from Major Larry Warden in May 2022 “informing him that he was being suspend